Featured Post

Side-Giggers And The Future

In the advertising world, moonlighting while holding down a full time job has been around for decades. Millennials have taken it to a new he...

Thursday, May 30, 2019

Update on Quibi TV

Last September 17, I put up a post entitled "The Allure of New TV." It talked about how Meg Whitman of ebay and Hewlett Packard fame and Jeff Katzenburg, an extremely prominent Disney alum, were teaming up to produce a new streaming device dubbed New TV at the time. The service would have short form video of extremely high quality with episodes lasting around 12 minutes apiece. The service would be available on wireless devices which translates largely to smartphones.

Recently, Ms. Whitman sat down with David Faber of CNBC for an interview. The link is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrFSs2vPp34

The service is slated to debut in 4th quarter of 2019 and has a formal name now--Quibi. The name is an abbreviation of Quick Bites. As usual, Mr. Faber gives a solid interview and Ms. Whitman is as direct as ever. One thing hit me and it may effect you the same way. The pricing structure for the service is $4.99 per month with advertising and $6.99 without commercial interruption. What is intriguing is $6.99 is the same price that Disney, one of Quibi backers, is charging for their new Disney + service.

I understand the concept and wish Quibi well. The target is people on the go, largely 18-35, who spend several hours on their mobile device daily and one hour of that watching video. Will they be willing to pay for it?

Informal polling that I have done shows a sharp, as you would expect, demographic divide regarding Quibi. Several 21 year olds told me that they loved the idea as Netflix episodes were too long. More mature people whom I would presume would be reaching for their reading glasses as I would, do not seem enamored with a service that they could only watch on their mobile device.

I see significant value on college campuses and people with long subway or mass transit commutes. Also, I suppose it might be a nice break during your lunch hour to catch an episode. Ms. Whitman admits that consolidation will hit the streaming space so maybe that is already baked in to the cake.

It will be very fun to watch how Quibi unfolds.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com


Sunday, May 5, 2019

Update: The Coming Streaming Wars

Last week, I put up a post entitled “Disney’s Big Challenge.” It generated lots of direct response to me as I projected that while Disney could compete easily with Netflix on a content basis given their vast properties and film franchises, they were behind in international growth and particularly in Artificial Intelligence (AI). If Disney Plus, their new streaming entry is to succeed this fall they will need to step up their game in AI and do it with some speed. Many readers agreed, and, as usual, a few said that I was out of touch with reality.

Well. In this this post, I will look at things from the point of view that I always prefer to take—the long game.

Soon, there are likely to be four major players in video streaming—Netflix, Apple, Amazon and Disney. Yes, other players will be there such as AT&T with HBO will be engaged, but, for this post, let us limit to the four media, retail or tech giants. Developing new programming is expensive. How much cash does each player have on hand at present? From Yahoo Finance at end of 1st quarter, 2019, we find:


Company Cash (Billions/U.S.)

Apple $86.43

Amazon           41.25

Disney               4.46

Netflix              3.71


A cursory look at the above numbers should tell you one thing: Apple and Amazon can definitely play the long game in streaming. Either one could lose a few billion a year for a long time with their streaming entry and still survive and prosper. Apple could continue to buy back shares and up their dividend by low double digits as they have done in recent years as they are now only paying about 30% of earning back to shareholders in the form of dividend hikes. Netflix, on the other hand, has borrowed a reported $3 billion this year to help finance the production of new made for Netflix series.

We also feel that Netflix is vulnerable to a price war. When Disney announced two weeks ago that Disney Plus would cost $6.99 per month, the press was surprised. By undercutting Netflix, they can “buy” some share. If the service gains significant traction prior to the next recession, people may cancel Netflix (and cable, I might add) and keep Disney Plus when the inevitable downturn hits. And, Amazon can tout that their rapidly improving (in my eyes) video service is free as the cost is embedded in each Amazon Prime subscription.

Another stat that a number crunching wonk such as I likes to look at is Leveraged Free Cash Flow. What the hell does that mouthful mean? A financial dictionary would describe it as the amount of money a company has left after paying off all its financial obligations. Here Apple is at $45.14 billion and Netflix $8.47 billion.  Investors like to look at this as do company management as it illustrates if a firm can make further investments in the company business or pay a bigger dividend.

And, Apple has modest debt while Netflix has very high debt levels. One more well known measure that investors look at would be the price/earnings ratio meaning how much do you pay for each dollar of earnings if you purchases shares in the company? Apple is a low key 15.86 while Netflix is at an eye popping 96.25 largely owed to  their rapid growth and little competition in recent years.

So, what is going to happen? I do not know. If Apple and/or Amazon go full throttle at Netflix they could starve them out in a few years. That is unlikely as they both have many irons in the fire and direct to consumer video is not their top priority at present. Disney is formidable from a content standpoint but will lose money on Disney Plus for a few years and it will take a while to roll it across the world. All three players will chip away at Netflix some for sure. Many of you reading this and the writer love Netflix as a service. Yet, in a free market, if someone appears to have a field to themselves others want to enter and do. The difference here is that two have the deepest pockets in corporate history and one has an unparalleled expertise in the content.

I would like to provide a hypothetical scenario. It is NOT, I repeat, not a forecast. About two years ago, I was among many who thought that Apple might buy Netflix. Then the shares of Netflix exploded upwards. So, Netflix might not be such an attractive target for Apple as it was until recently. What if Apple decided to form an alliance with Disney or even decided to purchase Disney? Bob Iger, the Disney chairman, has sat on the Apple board of directors for several years. In a recent interview with David Faber on CNBC, Iger said that he recuses himself when the topic of Apple’s foray in to video comes up. At the same time, Reed Hastings, CEO of Netflix, is resigning from the Facebook board, just as Facebook is reported to be entering the streaming space as well. Hmmm. Interesting.

Netflix has the lead, both domestically and internationally. And, they have millions of loyal viewers such as you and I. Yet, Frederick the Great allegedly said it right in Prussia nearly 300 years ago—“God is on the side of the big battalions.” Apple and Amazon are the big battalions for sure and Apple/Disney would trump anything imaginable.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com

Monday, April 29, 2019

Disney's Big Challenge

On April 12th, Bob Iger, CEO of Disney, unveiled the long awaited plans for Disney Plus, a streaming service that would be competing directly with Netflix. Media reports consistently mentioned that a collective gasp went up in the audience when Iger announced that the new Disney entry would cost  a subscriber $6.99 per month or $69.99 for a complete year. Clearly, it was priced very attractively for all kinds of households and well below what all of us are paying for Netflix.

The Disney franchise is a strong one going back to 1937’s “Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs.” Today, they have the current Disney studios, legacy films, the Fox film library and great franchises such as Pixar, Marvel, and Star Wars. This weekend their new “Avengers” entry garnered well over a billion dollars at the box office. Disney Plus, according to Iger, will also be the exclusive venue for 30 years of “The Simpsons.” So, to put it mildly, Disney is the king of content in the media world. Disney projects 90 million subscribers to Disney Plus by 2024. Many media analysts put it somewhat lower at 50-60 million but one generally expects bullishness at the time of a major announcement.

A lot of people are stopping here which strikes me as a big mistake. Let me be clear. I have great admiration for Bob Iger. He is not just the greatest media executive today but one of the greatest leaders, in my opinion, across all industries both domestic and international. He is very shrewd and saw how the media world was evolving. Iger knew that he had to do something as commercial avoidance continued to advance and Netflix and other video alternatives gobbled up more and more viewing time with direct to consumer plans.

To me, too many observers are focusing solely on the video content. Disney has to transform itself from a largely legacy or conventional provider to a strong streaming entity. To me, they can do that. They have many talented people on board and have the hammer of abundant content to execute it. Many say that Iger has delayed his retirement for a few years to oversee the transition.

Looking across the world, it is clear that Netflix has won the streaming battle with 160 million + subscribers in countless countries (despite this, they are not a big moneymaker). So, Disney, even under the best case scenario is not going to unseat Netflix overnight or even in several years. Disney faces a big or huge challenge that few people are mentioning but I feel is key to the Disney Plus and even their corporate future. As mentioned, Disney has lots of content and nobody does it better. The edge to me that Netflix has is not with their subscriber base but with their amazing lead in Artificial Intelligence (AI). Look closely at Netflix. Their logarithm is not good—it is amazing. When in college, some friends and I ran the film society on campus. We became devotees of classic films. Over the years, I have reviewed over 3,000 films for Netflix. Using my preferences, they have NEVER recommended a film that I did not like. Not once.

They can create original programming by looking at their viewer profiles and tastes and putting together shows that might not have huge broad appeal but build loyalty among a fair sized number of aficionados. Some reports claim that they have users divided in to over 1,000 buckets and tailor programs to them.

This to me is the big hurdle that Disney will face as they launch Disney Plus on November 12th. They can produce content—some good, some great. They have deeper pockets than Netflix and can lose money on their Plus entry for quite a while. What they need to do as they transform their company is get up to speed and quickly on AI. That is the issue that will be key going forward on whom will be standing profitably years from now in the video world.

Very soon, I will put up a post regarding Netflix vs. Disney vs. Apple. Watch for it!

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com or leave a message on the blog

Friday, March 22, 2019

Programmatic Advertising and The Death of Editorial Environment

This morning, my wife and I both opened our laptops and over coffee began to read THE NEW YORK TIMES.  She directed me to the top of the masthead where there was a link to a new Cartier commercial  featuring the news that the Hudson Yards location was now open. The 30 second spot was beautifully done and featured the iconic Cartier panther that has been seen in their video work in recent years. I was impressed by the execution but also the wonderful placement. A blue chip, sophisticated and cosmopolitan audience such as that of the Times would be ideal for the Cartier message.

I bring this up as, a few weeks ago, I heard from my most strident critic, a young man who sees me as a supercilious old fart. His comments are sometimes interesting, occasionally valid and often more than a bit mean. He asked why I did not write about Programmatic Advertising more in MR and suggested that I did not even know what it was.

These two separate events have inspired this modest post.

To those of you not currently in the ad game, here is my brief explanation of Programmatic Advertising:

Let us say that you would like to visit Vancouver, British Columbia, one of my favorite places in North America. You compare hotel prices, Air B&B’s and conventional B&B’s, shake your head at the stiff prices and do not book any rooms. Like it or not, you now have a Vancouver cookie on your device. The next morning you log on to check your e-mail or the action in the overseas markets. Your cookies are passed on to an ad exchange. The exchange in the blink of an eye auctions off the information from the cookies to the entity in Vancouver who is most willing to pay for it. The ad of the winner of this instantaneous auction is loaded in to your current web page in a flash.

Is there anything wrong with this? Not really although when shopping I can never get rid of the ad for a novelty tie that I did not want for months! Yet there is one tragic flaw to it for me. Programmatic advertising virtually dismisses quality content. When I was a young pup in the advertising business decades ago, it was drilled in to me that while demographic delivery was important, almost of equal value was the editorial environment that the selected media vehicle provided. More importantly, as marvelous as the Cartier spot was this morning, the environment of THE NEW YORK TIMES counted for a lot as well.

A vehicle that had quality content merited a premium price. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL was great for business advertisers as were FORBES, FORTUNE, AND BUSINESS WEEK. Even in TV, I worked hard and had my teams cherry pick programming that seem to fit the lifestyle or interest of our primary target even though Nielsen gender and age data may have suggested other choices.

With programmatic buying, a quality site such as the Times is not differentiated at times from a tractor pull page or perhaps a very suggestive site.

When we paid a premium for a high quality environment we still thought that it was a good value proposition.

So, to my acerbic young friend, I do see the value of programmatic buying in reaching people efficiently. At the same time, something is lost when quality content takes a back seat or all but disappears.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com


Thursday, March 7, 2019

Illigitimi non Carborundum

During World War II, British intelligence apparently adopted “Illigitimi non Carborundum” as their mantra as the powers that be gave them impossible tasks and never seem satisfied with their results.

The first time that I heard the expression I was a sophomore in college. I had just been chewed out by a literature professor after a class ended. He was rude and did it in front of other people as a new group of students was filing in to the classroom. A young political science professor witnessed the whole thing. When the mean spirited prof left, the young one said to me, “Illigitimi non Carborundum.” I told him that my Latin was more than rusty and he whispered, “Don’t let the bastards grind you down.” Over the years, I have embraced that term when things get a bit rocky. In fact, I have a tie that has the term embossed on it. I wear it when I need it a jolt of confidence.

The older I get, it continues to amaze me how negative people can be. As recently as a few years ago, I told someone of a (modest) plan that I had been working on for some time. His response, with a sneer, was “someone like you could never do that.” I have been hearing that line or something similar to it since 1964 when I spent four years studying with the Christian Brothers who proved to be the least Christian people whom I have ever encountered. For some reason, people often want to cut us down and tell us what we cannot do. After I learned to embrace the Illigitimi non Carborundum mantra, my attitude became “who is going to stop me?”  Listening to valid criticism is valuable but comments from the mean spirited are hurtful and worthless.

I have learned to play things close to the vest. As I have written a number of times in this space, most things do not work out or at least the way we originally saw them. So, I am very careful about telling people what I am doing. My mind is going 24/7, I am an omnivorous reader, and I eat demographic, consumer and financial trends for breakfast . Markets have enthralled me since I was eight. I will never kick back and retire.

So I urge all of you to never give up on your dreams. Yet, be careful with whom you share them. Someone, usually an observer rather than a participant, will try and cut you down. Endorsing the wisdom of the Illigitimi non Carborundum cloak will help you overcome more than you can imagine.

By the way, there will be a Latin purist or two reading this. The term “Illigitimi non Carborundum is not proper Latin. Academics refer to it as “Dog Latin” or a mock translation. So be it. The term has helped me a lot when dealing with difficult people and kept my chin up. I bet that it can do the same for you.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com

Sunday, February 24, 2019

The Global Reach of Netflix

A few weeks ago I put up a post asking if any streaming service could catch Netflix. Most respondents said no and agreed with me that Netflix had a commanding lead in the streaming space. A few said that Disney’s new service and Amazon Prime Video would chip away at the lead that Netflix has and a few mentioned Apple getting in to the game as well. One topic that I alluded to in the earlier piece was not mentioned by anyone—Netflix is a powerhouse outside of the U.S. Depending on the estimates that you look at, Netflix has somewhere between 140 and 160 million subscribers. Last year, for the first time, Netflix had more non-US subscribers than domestic ones and their growth is largely overseas as move through 2019. Netflix now is available in 190 countries. They are licensing or producing hundreds of programs in many languages and their knowledge of what viewers like in different cultures is getting stronger by the day thanks to their shrewd use of Big Data.

When people tell me that Amazon will soon catch up, I can only smile. Amazon is a superb on line retailer and will be tough competition at some point for sure. Yet, keep this in mind. Netflix does basically one thing—providing programming. Amazon operates globally as well and many perceive Amazon Prime Video as a free service as it is embedded in an Amazon Prime subscription. The rub is that Netflix can deliver their service to virtually anyone, anywhere who has high speed internet. Amazon Prime operates globally but does not deliver to every podunk village in the world. The costs of delivery would be prohibitive at present and many overseas customers cannot afford a prime subscription. They would have to spin off Amazon Prime Video or make it available freestanding to go head to head with Netflix. It would take years to be a viable GLOBAL competitor to Netflix. Disney needs to crawl and then walk with Disney + before traveling abroad with the service. So, the head start that Netflix has appears to give them an advantage that could protect them for several years which is a lifetime in today’s tech world.

So, is Netflix completely safe?  I see one little known (in the U.S) but viable player out there who could possibly upset Netflix’ global juggernaut. We have all heard of the BAT’s in China. Baidu is the Google of China, Alibaba is the Amazon of China, and TenCent is the gaming giant of China. A fourth player is iQIYI (pronounced eye-chee-yee) which is rapidly being nicknamed by securities analysts as the Netflix of China. iQIYI is a bit different than Netflix in that it has free content with advertising plus a subscription service that others use. The subscription video service now has 80 million subscribers and is growing. iQIYI has the same cost issue that Netflix has in that it is expensive to produce original programming. Also, Alibaba and TenCent have a minor entry in streaming video at present which could grow.

A few rumors exist that say that iQIYI may move beyond China’s borders. This could put a crimp in Netflix growth especially in many Asian countries. FYI, iQIYI now trades on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol IQ (not a recommendation but you may want to read their annual report as I did).

This is what I love about the free market. When some company appears set, they find that their competitive advantage is not sustaining for long. So, even mighty Netflix has to stay innovative and run a bit scared. To date, they have done a fine job of it.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

Media in the Next Recession

The last recession in the United States has been projected to have occurred from December, 2007 to June, 2009 (Federal Reserve estimate). Some may argue a month or two on either side but most would agree that those dates are very close to real. Now, with a volatile stock market and recent weak retail numbers, some are calling for the next recession to occur late this year. Others say 2020 or even 2021. Economist Paul Samuelson who wrote the textbook that many of you had in Economics 101 was a winner of the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. He had a sharp wit and once said, “the stock market has forecast nine of the last five recessions.” So, no one really knows when it will occur but virtually all agree that this recovery is getting quite long in the tooth and that a recession is inevitable. Yet, it could be six months away or several years from now.

Several readers have asked me what will happen to the media world the next time the United States economy plunges into a recession. I stress that I, like most, have no idea when the downturn will hit. Also, I have based my forecast below on the assumption that the next recession will be a “garden variety” recession and not something mirroring the 2008 debacle that was the worst that we had experienced since 1933.

With no more disclaimers, here goes:

1) Newspaper—this once mighty medium has been in decline for two decades. We project that more titles will go under and a handful will successfully make the transition to digital only delivery. The Wall Street Journal, New York Times, and The Washington Post will survive but earnings will be hurt. Also harmful will be the lack of investigative journalism done in mid-sized markets. Crooked mayors and city councils will sometimes escape needed scrutiny.

2) Magazine—many long time titles will disappear but a handful will buck the trend and, a few, such as COSMOPOLITAN and VANITY FAIR may prance through the media bear market smiling.

3) Radio—young people will continue to avoid their once favorite medium of two generations ago. There will be consolidation but revenue growth will be nil. Sports and political talk will have their niches but it will be tough. Small market players will suffer a great deal.

4) Outdoor—the last authentic mass medium is not going anywhere but prices may get more realistic. Watch for boards staying up a long time with the same message or PSA billboards (especially Smokey the Bear). A sure indicator that the market is soft.

5) Cable—this one is a stick of dynamite. Some tell me that cable can go thru the next downturn relatively unscathed as TV will be many people’s only meaningful entertainment option. I respectfully disagree. When things get tight next time, many young adults will want to meet their college loan payments. Cutting the cord on cable can save them $100-120 over month in many cases. They can still get their video for less with Netflix, Hulu+, Amazon Prime Video, Freestanding HBO and ESPN, and the new Disney +. A few other players may enter the streaming game before the recession hits. People can cobble together a package of streaming options for a fraction of what they now pay for cable. Also, we see a real sleeper out there that does not get mentioned much. You Tube! It is free but has a tremendous amount of content. People who have an internet connection and are really strapped for cash will gravitate there. When I visit my county library each week, I see dozens of people at the free terminals watching You Tube. Sadly, all appear to be really down on their luck. You Tube is a great comfort to them.  Cable will try and hold people with more attractive “Trifecta” packages of Phone, Internet and Cable access but I see a significant loss if unemployment really jumps.

6) TV—some have written to me stating that local TV will have a renaissance if cable gets hit. Maybe a bit in terms of viewing and it is clear that several million folks have purchased antennas to get local station reception in recent years. Yet, advertising will not be vibrant in local TV. Network TV may still have the “upfront” cavalry charge in spring but it will be muted and could be the last one.

7) On line and Social Media—continued growth but at a slower pace than presently.

To stress again, I do not know when the next recession will rear its ugly head. When it does, some long time players will be hurt and a surprising number of time honored media vehicles will go down for the count.

If you would like to contact Don Cole directly, you may reach him at doncolemedia@gmail.com